sd.gif (2133 bytes)
Robert Todd Carroll

 the truth is in here!
SkepDic.com

vertline.gif (1078 bytes)  

Immanuel Velikovsky's Worlds in Collision, Ӹ Ű  "浹ϴ "

Reading something they can understand, that seems to make sense, that presents itself as technically competent, non-scientists are easily gulled by fake science.  --Henry H. Bauer   

1950 Ӹ Ű "浹ϴ " å ´. å ٸ ٵ ݼ ֱٱ ̾ٴ ư ־. ̷ Ÿ ߴٸ, ⿣ յ ´ ͸ ̰ų Ȥ ڵ ̿ ū ҵ ų ʴ´. Ű ε ַп ȭ ٰŷ ̴. ׸ε ׳ (Ű ݼ ϴ) 콺(Ű Ѵ.) Ӹ ƢԴ. ȭ ٸ ߱, ε, Ʈ, ̽, ߽ ȭ Ҿ "ݼ ִٰ ¾ ༺ Ŀ ༺ Ǿ" ϰ ִ.[Worlds in Collision (New York: Dell, 1972), p. 182.]

Դٰ, Ű ݼ- ༺ ϱ⵵ ϰ ĸ(fly) ̿ϰ ִ. ,

ٸ п ߴ. ǽ ݼ ̾ ֱ 糭 Ű Ǿ. [p. 181]

ݼ 񼺿 Ƣ Ǿ ̷ ƿԴ. Ÿ ߻ϴ ſ ϰ ϴµ ߴ. ֱ⿡ ϰ ִ õ ߻, ޶ѱ ߻ ̷ ο иϴ. [p. 192]

⼭ ǹ ݼ þ κ κп ̳ Բ ֹ(larvae) ؿͼ ״°ϴ ̴. ݼ ĸ Ű ִٴ ſ ǹ ִ ̴. [p. 193]

׵ ֹ ȤѰ ߰ſ ߵٴ Ͱ Ұ ⿡ ִٴ ݼ ɼ Ұ ʰ Ѵ. [p. 195]

츮  Ư ְڴ°? ׷ ġĿ δ δ. Ƣ ؼ 󸶳 ʿ ΰ ׸ ߰ſ ݼ µ 750o K Ǵµ 3500 ̸ Ѱ? ̷ ϴ ̴. 츮 "浹ϴ " ̷ Ǵ ãƺ ̴. ״ ãƺ ִ ȭ, , Ȥ Ű ༺п ´ ʵ̴. ̰ ʰ ſ λ ƴϰŶ â ڽ Ѵٴ ƴϴ. ̰ ſ λ װ ƴϴ. װ ƴϴ.

Ű ƴ ״ ˷ Ϳ ؼ ȭ װ ߰ Ȯϰ ִµ ϰ ƴ϶ ſ ״ ڿ Ģ ߰ų ڿ Ģ õ ص ݰ ٸٰ ߴ. ׸ ״ ȭ õа ַ ϰų ϴµ ִٴ 翬ϰ ϴ ϴ. ϸ ȭп ݴ븦 ϴ âó ״ ̵ Ѵ. õڵ̳ õڵ  Ǵ ̷ Ʋȴٰ Ѵ. Ű ž âں Ѱ ư. ֳϸ ״ ȭ ؼ ִ. װ ȭ ̰ ޾Ƶ鿴 װ ̶ . ȭ ° ؼ ִٸ ״ ο ʾҴ. ȭ ̳ óǾ. ȭ ´´ٸ ״ װ ޾Ƶ鿴 װ ϴ Ĵ ؼߴ. ݸ鿡 ȭ ʴ´ٸ ״ ߴ. ؼ, ״ ȭ, , ׸ 縦 ʾҴ.

ŵ ȭ Ģ ʴ 찡 ִ. ̶ 츮 Ģ̶ 迡 Ǽ ؾѴ. ׷Ƿ Ģ ǰ ¾ƾ ϴ Ģ ϴ ƴϴ. [p. 11]

Ű ڵ ׸ õ Ѵ. ׷ٸ ״ ̺ ̺񿪻 õ̴.

״ и â ִ. ȭ 缺 ſ ̰, и ׷ ϰ δ. ̵ 浹 ǿ ƴ ͵߿ ̴. 츮 ݺ 3500 츮 ũ ༺ 츮 ٰ´ٰ غ. ̰ 츮 Ź ġµ 츮 ༺ ߵ ϰ ٽ ϰ , 츮 ִ ༺ ݺ κ ̷  ̾ Ѵ... ׸ ¾ ߾[ȣ 10: 12-13] ׸ , dz, ݺ, , ȫ, ϴÿ ͵ Ѵ.  츮 浹ߴ ü ũ⸦ ʾҴ. ̷ ߿ ̾߱⸦ ִ ϴ  ̾߱⸦ ڿ ־ ̶ ̴. ׸ ̾߱⸦ ̴. 󿡴 ׷ ϴ .

Ű 츮 ̷ ʾҴ° å " ǽ"̶ 忡 ϰ ִ[p. 302 ff.]״ б ̷  ̵ ư ִ. ʹ ũ ϱ⿣ ʹ ؼ 츮 츮 ǽļӿ ξٴ ̴. 츮 ȭ 迡 ٰ Ű ǥ̴.

ɸм ϴ ϰ ũ ٸٰ . ׵ ޵鿡  ܻ ٽ س. η м 迡 ̳ Ƽ м ־ (Ʊ ) ް Ѵ. [p. 12]

۾ ɸм ϸ鼭 Ű װ ϴ ̻ ϰ ִ. ɸм ̷а ȯ Ű ȯ󺸴 ణ ޾Ƶ̱ ̴. ΰ ̺, ׸ ¿ ٰŸ ΰ ִ.

ֱ ַп å ѱ Ű ̷п ؼ ٴ ״ ϵ ƴϴ. ڵ ׵ ̷ ϴ Ϳ ؼ а谡 ׵ ݴǴ ̵ ﴩ ִ Ŷ Ѵ. ̷ ڴ Ƹ Į ̰ ̴. ٸ 嵵 Ű κ ֵȴ.

ð Ż(Charles Ginenthal) ̰ǰ Ű å ̰ Ż ġ ϰ ⸸ ߴٰ ߴ. Ű ĸŰ ϴ Stephen J. Gould and Immanuel Velikovsky, Essays in the Continuing Velikovsky Affair ٸ Ʈ ϰ ִ. ̰ Ű ׸ ϴ ڷ ̴. ̰ ذȴٴ ̰ Ű Ͼ Ѵ. Ű ڵ ̰ ""ϸ Ű ڰ ̱ ؼ "bad science" ߴٰ ߴ. ̰ ׷ 忡 ƴ 亯 ʾҴ. Ӹ ƴ϶ " Ҽ к(Science as a Candle in the Dark "( : 'Ƿ ϴ '̰ Ҽ к Դϴ.) Ű ʾƼ ġ ׵ ʹ ̶ Ű ϴ ߴ. ̰ Ű ߽ɵǴ 忡 "浹ϴ " 29 ߴ[Sagan, pp. 81-127]. ũ ݼ- ϰ Ӱ ̰, Ʈε ǹ (긮ε ǹ ) ߸ ״ٰ ߴ. ̽ Ʈο ѱ ȫعٴٸ  Ż ְ ߴٰ Ѵ. źȭҳ źȭ (ؽƮ ٸ) ϴÿ ̰ 40 縷 õ Ǿ Ȳϴ ε鿡 Ǵ Ϳ Ǿ. ( : źȭ "" źȭҴ Դϴ. Ű ΰ иߴٴ ǹϴ ̷ ǥ ϴ.)

Ű ȸ ߾ (ȣư ¾ ߶ ) ȣ ־. ȭ ̽ο ƽøƱ ݸ Ѵ. ׷ٰ ¾ ٽ Ȯ ϰ ȸϱ ߴ.

ո Ѱ Ư¡ װ ׷ ̾߱ ̴. ո DZ ؼ 亯 ִٴ δ ϴ. װ ׷ ƾ Ѵ. ׷ Ƿ İ , ϴ о Ģ 鿡 ؼ ϰ ־ Ѵ. ΰ ȭչ  ȣۿ ϴ° Ϸ ̰ ȭ ⺻ ϸ ո̶ . ̷ ϸ ƴ϶ ׽Ʈ, , ݹ, ׸ ׽Ʈ, , ̳ ݺؼ ̴. о ̹ װ ڽ ̷ å (burden of proof) ſ ũ. ̰ ̹ Ģ ִ о߿ ȴ. Ǹ ̷, , ̹ Ϲ ޾Ƶ鿩 ̷а ġ ʴ ̶ ̸ å ִ. Ǹ ̷ ϴ ؾ Ǹ ؾ Ѵ. ̰ ̷ Ʋ ٰ ؼ ƴ϶ ̰ ư ̱ ̴. ̷ Ʋ , ڱ Ÿ ̷ ᱹ ׸ Ǿ ڸ ϰ ȴٰ ص ̷ ޾Ƶ鿩  ٸ ̷ ̷ ޾Ƶ̴ ո ƴϴ.

̰ǿ ϸ, Ű Ϻδ ,  Ģ ٰ Ѵ. ̰ п ſ Ȯϰ ̴. ̰   ߷ ̱ ݼó ū Ǿ ؼ ʿ  Ͽ Ű 忡 ݴ ߴ. ̰  õ ų ̶ ־. ̷ ߻뿡 Ƣ ̴. ̰ ٷ ̴.   ַ Ƣ ȴٸ ̰ ڵ ̸ ̰ ݼ ʴ´[Sagan, p. 97]. ̰ ߷ Żϴµ ʿ ӵ ּ ʼ 60km̶ ߴ. ׷ ӵ ʼ 63 km Ѿ ¾踦  ȴ. "ſ ̸ ׷ Ű δ." [Sagan, p. 98]̷ "¾ 1Ⱓ ϴ ݱ ÷ 1質 ̴... ٸ ų ʿ , 񼺿 ݼ Ƣ ¾ ǥ  ͺ ξ ̸ ̰ 񼺺ٵ ξ ̴. [Sagan,m p. 98]

Ű ̼ װ 忡 Ÿ ʴ´ٴ Ϳ ִ. Ϻδ Ƿ 巯. ַ ȭ Ƿ Ȯؾ߸ Ѵٴ ٰϰ ִ. ״ ݵ ʴ ƴ϶ ٰŷ ޾Ƶ ʾҴ. Ϲ ״ ̷ ؼ õ ȭ ƹ͵ ʾҴ. ó δ ڱ ٴ ϴ. ׷ ׷ ϰ Ϸ Ű ̷ ̰ 濡 ϵ  ϴµ شٰų Ʈ Ͱ ¾ ϴµ Ǵ ٲپ߸ ϴ ؾ߸ Ѵ.   

, ̰ Ű ϰ Ͽ° θ , ؾ߸ Ѵ. ̻ ð Ǵ ִٸ ̰ǰ Ż о.  ٿ Encyclopedia of the Paranormal Ű ׸ 鼭 ̰ ʾҰų, Ȥ "򰡵鿡 ؼ  Ű ̵ ϱ ؼ Ϻ Ѱų Ȥ Ʋ ־." Į ̰ ְǰ Ͽ. μ "ī " б Ű ߴ. Ű ̰ 忡 ̸ ̰ ,  ų ڰų Ȥ ϰų ⸸ ƴ϶ Ű п ɰ ̴. 翡 ̸ ̷̶ ״ , Ȥ Ǿ ؼ ϰų ̴. Ű  а κ 浹ϰ , ȭ Ͽ Ư ( ʿ) Ȯ ϰ ִ ó δ.  ̷ ״ L. Ϲٵ ϴ. ״ ־߸ Ǵ ޱ׷̶ ״ ޱ׷ , ʿ䰡 ִٴ ˰ . ׵ ȭ ȭϱ ؼ ʿ âϴ "â" ϴ.

õ ׸ : Erich von D?iken and Zecharia Sitchin.


б ڷ

reader comments

Bauer, Henry H. Beyond Velikovsky, (University of Illinois Press: Urbana and Chicago, 1984).

Bauer, Henry. H. "Immanuel Velikovsky," in The Encyclopedia of the Paranormal edited by Gordon Stein (Buffalo, N.Y.: Prometheus Books, 1996).

Friedlander, Michael. The Conduct of Science (New Jersey: Prentice-Hall, 1972).

Friedlander, Michael W. At the Fringes of Science, (Boulder, Colorado: Westview Press,1995).

Gardner, Martin. Fads and Fallacies in the Name of Science (New York: Dover Publications, Inc., 1957), ch. 3.

Goldsmith, Donald (Ed.) Scientists Confront Velikovsky. (Foreword by Isaac Asimov) (Cornell University Press, 1977).

Morrison, David. "Velikovsky at Fifty - Cultures in Collision on the Fringes of Science" Skeptic, Vol. 9 No. 1, 2001.

Sagan, Carl. Broca's Brain (New York: Random House, 1979), ch. 7, "Venus and Dr. Velikovsky".

Velikovsky, Immanuel. Worlds in Collision (New York: Dell, 1972).

Copyright 2000
Robert Todd Carroll

larrow.gif (1051 bytes) victim soul

Last updated 11/13/00

von D?iken rarrow.gif (1048 bytes)