sd.gif (2133 bytes)
Robert Todd Carroll

 logo.gif (4146 bytes)
SkepDic.com

The Skeptic's Refuge

vertline.gif (1078 bytes)

R & R

The Rediscovery of the Human Soul
by L. Ron Hubbard
Scientology, 1996


߿ ٸ Ѱ ? Ż, Ĵϻ, ž, , ̾Ƴƽ?

ٲپ, ̵ ߿ ٸ Ѱ ? 뱳, ̽, , ұ, ̾? ڿ ׵ ȣ ޸ ̾ ƴϴ. ̰ ɵ , ǽ絵 , ġ ֿ ȸ ü ǰ ϴ . ̰ ַ ȭ ħ ؼ ο ̳ ̷ο ͵ ϴ ͵ ƴϴ. ׷, ׵ ׵ ö ׸ auditing ؼ Ǿٰ Ѵ. ׸ ̷ ׸ ü ؼ Ӹӿ ִ ȥ ȥ ܾ, ȥ ؼ ָϰ ϰ ȥ ؼ ұ ϴ ȸ Ż̶ ϰ ϰ ִ. ̾ öа dz üӿ ؼ ϳ Ϳ Ұϴ.

1993 ̱ Internal Revenue Service ̾ ˰ ִ. IRS ó ̾ 鼼 ִ ʾҾ. ׷ Ҽ۰ ϳ ذϸ ٸ ϴ ׵ ϴ IRS ׺ϰ Ҵ. ׷ ̰ ǰδ 鼼 ־ ̶ Ѵ. ƴϸ, ΰ ׷ ϵ ̾ ؾ߸ ؾ Ѵ.

߿ ٸ Ѱ ? νŸ, , , θ, ٵ? ʹ ? ̾Ʈ ̾ ̶ ƴϴ. ̾ L. Ϲ ʰ ̸ Ұ ̾ ʸ ϴ  The Rediscovery of the Human Soul ݰ Ǹ ǰ ̴.

̾ ƴ϶, װ ü ΰ? װ auditing̶ ī Ǵ ̻ Ƴ ̴. ̾ ̸ ٿ Ѵٸ װ ö Ʈ ҷְ ׵ ħ ̶̻ ҷְ ʹ. ̰ ö ϳ Ŀ . ̰ Ʈ󱳿 ʱ ⵶ źƮ ϰ ĥ, ں Ҹ ϰ ִ. ̾ ູ, , ǰ شٰ Ѵ. Ƹ ׷ 𸥴. audit ̳ ؼ . ׷, ̾ ٰŷ ϰ ִ Ư ׵ ""̶ ϴ ̵ ؼ ִ. ̾ ⺻ ƴϰ ̸̻, ٵ ħ ٽɿ п ٺ 밨 ִ.

Ź ʾ The Rediscovery of the Human Soul ѱ ޾Ҵ. ̰ ũ ø öа 繫Ƿ . L. Ron Hubbard Public Relations Director Kaye Copleyκ å ؼ ѹ ֱ ϴ ޾Ҵ. Copley å "̾ ⺻ 信 ظ ϰ, ̾ ϴ ޸鿡 ִ Ϳ ؼ ϱ ؼ" ٰ Ͽ. ׸ "츮 ̾ ˰ ʹ" ؿԴ. ׳ ִ.

, λ ʴ.

ϰڴ. å ſ Ƹ . Ų , ½ϴ , Į , ׷ Ǿִ. Ŀ ̺ ÷ ׸̰ڴ.

, 캸.

å Ϲٵ尡 ų Ϲٵ忡 縦 å̴. "An Introduction to L. Ron Hubbard" ö ߿ ̾ ִ ͺ Ŀٶ ٰ Ѵ. ̰ ſ λ̴.  ؼ ũٴ ٴ ƴϸ ٳ ٴ ǹ̵ ƴϴ.

̾ "ֿ " Ҹ , ߵ, , ׸ ȸ Ҿȿ ذå ִٰ Ѵ. ̷ ̾ ٸ ֵ ´. ̾ "̷̳ " ƴ "Ȯ (axioms)" ٰŸ " ö"̶ θ. ׷ ̷ νķ Ÿ ٰŸ ̴. ٵ ''  ̾Ƴƽ ϴµ ϰ ִ. ״  " Ȯ " ǹ̷ ϰ ִ. ڱ- "ü װ  κе ũ"ų Ȥ (ʼ ), Ǵ θ ޾Ƶ鿩 ִ (principle) " ִ" ̴. ǿ ؼ (statements)̰ų ̰ų Ȥ ٰŸ ̴.  Ѵ. ̿ ٰŸ ڷ 츮 ΰ ǽĿ ؼ üȭǾ ϰ ؼǾ ϴµ ̰ Ȯ  Ѵ. ̰Ϳ ؼ νķڵ öڵ п ǵ ִٰ ϸ ٷ ν ⲯؾ ɼ Ȯ Ѵٴ ̴. ٵ ̰ ϰ , ڵ鵵 ̴. õϳ ̷ ̳ ո ٴ ݰ ִ.

̾ ⲯؾ ǿǷ ְڴ. ׵ " ´°" ͻ̶ Ѵ. ϴ "츮 ɷ ̰, ູϰ ϸ ΰ ǰ ɷ ְ °?" ̷ Ȯ Ƹٿ ׵ ָԿ ִ. ׵ ̷ ʹ ȣϱ  ڷḦ ¥ Ƿ ݴǴ ؼ ӽù ʿ伺 . ̾ ƴϰų ƴ϶ ʹ ȣؼ .   

̿ 츮 ٸ ö ߰ϴµ ٷ ̻ " ױ " ö̶ ϰ Ѵ. ̾Ʈ鿡 罺 Ȧϸ о ϰ ʹ. ϴ ̻ п Ӹ ƴ϶, ߿ 縯 ȸ ο ¸ 𸣴 ̾ , ڿ ֵ ̴. å ʷα״ ̾ 1 ϰ ִٰ Ѵ. (̷ ̸, α ȭ ٰ Ѵٸ, ̾Ʈ Ǵµ 10,000 ɸ.

auditing ʿϴ.

ʰ , ö ǾǷ Ϲ ϰ ޾Ƶ̱ ƴ. ״ 츮 " " Ѵ. 츮 ˾Ƴ װ ġϱ ؼ "auditing" ʿϴٰ Ѵ. ** auditing ſ ߴ. ״ auditing κ(װ ϴ ȸ) ߰ߴ. 츮 Ѹ ϱ ؼ auditing ʿ ִٴ ̴. ġ ó ޵ȴ. ̰ ƴϰ žӰ ۵ ƴϴ. ǻ, ž "" ѹ ޵ ʴ´. ּ ٸ ƹ Ҽ ص ׵ žӿ ٰŸ ΰ ִٴ Ѵ. ¶ų, auditing 鼺ó ᰡ ƴϸ auditing ϱ ؼ ǽؾ Ѵ. ٸ ڴ " " ǹ̸ ȴ.

Ϲ "Į Ʈ" װ λ п ٺ ̶ θ Ұ޴´. öп ؼ ƴ ״ ϴ Ϳ ʴ´ٴ ִ. Ƹڷ ķ ϴ öڴ   ų ϳ . ϰ ** , Ƴ ؼ Ȥ Ƴ ؼ ִ ü Ѵٴ ̴. ״ װ ִٴ 1937 ߴٴ ̴. װ ϱ 迡 ȹ Ʋȴٴ ߴٴ ̴. ̸ ϱ⿣ ** 󸶸ũ ߴٴ δ. 󸶸ũ ȹ ൿ ļ 鼭 ȭ Ͼٰ ߾. ΰ , ȭ а Ӹ ƴ϶ ũ ó ̹Ƿ ִ ׵ ڵ ̿ ſ иϴ.

̷ ü ü ϰ ִ ü ΰ? ״ ׸ƴ ߸ ̰ ׵ ڼտ ִٴ ̴.

1. ״ ׸ƿ 帣 ־ ƹ ȿ .

2. ״ ̹ ׸ƿ ⸦ ־ ׸ư ̷ ؼ "".

3. ״ ⸦ ̿ؼ ؼ " ־."

4. ״ ٽ ٲپ. ׸ƴ ׵ 迬 ؼ "."

5. ׸ 2,3 ڼյ鵵 ؼ "." ̰ ׵ ׵ û θ 迬 ߸ ޾Ƶ鿴 ̴.

L Ron H ׸ ο ׵ θκ 迬⸦ ɷ Ǿٰ ߴ. ״ ׸ 밡 Ƴ ؼ 迬κ "" ߴ.  ſ ִٴ ߰ߴ.

1.  ׸ư ٴ װ ˾Ҵ°? Ʈ( : ˷ ҷ Դϴ.)  ̶ ־°?  ״  ׸ư 賿 ؼ 賿 ãư ʾҴٴ Ȯ ־°? ׸Ƹ ȭϴ ŷ, ʴ .

2. ڴ ߿ 迡 ؼ  ߴ.

3. ״ 츮 װ ׸Ƹ " " ߿ 迬 ֱ  ٴ ϱ⸦ ٶ ִ. ¼ ׸ư ¥ ** ְ ִ 𸥴.

4. ״ ׸ư ׵ ƹ ʴµ ߸ǴϿ ٸ, ̰ ڿ ΰ (X-factor) , ̰ ϴ ǹ̸ ִٰ ϴ . Ƹ ׷ 𸥴. ׷ ƴ ϴ ϳ û иϴ. L. Ϲٵ ó ǥ,  ǰ  ʴ° ɷ  ̶ Ƴ ٴ ü ſ ̴.

Ϲٵ尡 ̶ ؼ ݷϰ ; 쿬 ϰ û ֻ ҿ ؼ ȴٴ ̾Ƿ ״ û ׸ư 븦 ŵ鼭 û ο ̴. "쿬 Ѵ." ƴϴ. 츮 ϴ ִ. δ ȭ ü  ִ ƴ϶ ٵ , ǵ ൿѴٴ ̴. ̷ ̷ ߷ žμ ƴ϶ ̶ ޾Ƶ̴ ʰ ȴٴ Ϳ ؼ ƾ߰ڴ.

п

Ϲ尡 з å ؼ ׻ 巯 ִ ִٸ װ п Ѹ 갨̴. ̿ ״ , Ȥ ȥ, Ǵ ̻ ϰ ̰ ̶ θ. ״ ݺ ȥ Ѵٴ Ͱ ȥ ȸ Ѵٴ Ӹ ƴ϶ ȥ ͵ Ÿ ٰ Ѵ. ̾ ϴ ̷  ڵ鿡 ο ִ ñ. ׵ 忡 ִٸ װ bad science ̴. ׷ ֵ ö ԵǾ ִ. ׸ ִ ȥ ڿ ̰ ϴ ̸ ٷ "" ϰ ִٴ ̻ ̴. ׷ ٵ尡 ݴϴ , ٽ ؼ, ڿ (ȥ ƴ϶) ü Ģ ٴ ׷ ƴϴ. ⿣ ο . ɷп ݴ ǰ ſ ̷ο ̴. , L Ron H £ ° ̴.

迡 ̾ ʸ ˾, 츮 L Ϲ ؼ ĺ غ Ǿ. Ϲٵ "Original Thesis" "̾Ƴƽ ź" 츮 츮 ڵ δ (final cause)̶  ̿ؼ ϴ ̻ڶ ߰ ִ. ̶ dz κ ڵ öڵ ̴. ( : Ƹڷ (formal cause), (material cause), (efficient cause), (final cause) 4 ٿ (Ȥ ) ؼ ߴ) ״ ڸ, '̳ Ͱῡ ʴ´ٰ ' ȭϰ ִ. " ü Ѵ" ̴. ֳϸ " ϱ "̸ ̷ ڵ鿡 ̸ ̴. ״ ̻ 迡 ϱ ̸ ´ٰ ϴ δ. ׷ װ ݴμ ݴϴ ֵ ڴٰ ϴ δ. , ״ ̻ ๰ ܼ߰ ɽ Ųٰ Ѵ. ״ 索 ȯ, , ׸ ź ΰ ִ ๰ ġκ ް ִٴ ϰ ִ. ǹ̷μ, Ϲٵ尡 ϴ ñ ü̴. ü Ѵٴ.

̷ ڽ ǻ鿡 ̰ ̳ Ȥ ڽ ؼ ƹ͵ ٴ ϰ ʴ 鿡 󸶳 ŷ ִ. ɸ ޾Ƶ ۿ , ȯڰ DZ⸦ ٶ ʴ´. 츮 츮 ϰ ;Ѵ. ׷ L. Ϲ ๰ ̵ ϰ , ൿ ϵ ΰ 翡 ϸ鼭 ö ߸ ϰ ִ. , ΰ ൿ ¶ Ű ؼ ϰ ؾ߸ ϴ ǥ ִٰ ü迡 ٰŸ ΰ ִ.

ź ̱ ؼ L ٵ а ǽ γ ۿ ȯŰ õ źϴ οϰ ִ. , ǽɽ.  title essay(1930뿡 ) а л "γ û ܹ ܹ ȿ ִٴ ." ߴٰ Ѵ. 츮 ڴ ɻؼ " ⿣ ڰ ִٴ Ȥ ȿ 𸥴." Ѵ. ׸ ״ "ɸڵ̳ ڵ ϴ ϴ ͺ ٰ Ǵ ̿ؼ" ǽϿ װ "γ 3 ۿ ٴ " ߰ߴٰ ϰ ִ. и ̷п ִٴ ٵ ϰ ִ. 츮 װ ؼ ϴٰ , ڵ ׿ Űа ֽ ˷ ʾҴٴ ִ. ̾ ̶ ̰, ֿ Ұ Ǿ ̴. ̾ ƴϸ ݰ̴. 踦 ϸ ڿ ü Ϸ õѴ. Űڰ ȥ ִ. ڷμ Űڴ γ 10,000,000,000,000 L. ٵ DZ⿣ ŭ ũ. (, ϳ £ ʿϰ ѹ ٽ ʴ´ٰ ϰ ο 80⵿ ʿ ϳ ȴٰ ϸ ʿ ͺ ּ 500質 ̴.) ̷ ǵ,  Ǵ ؿ и ɷ ϴ ǰ̶ ϴ ̾Ʈ鿡Դ ̴. ̷ ̻ ġ . ٸ 鿡 󸶳 ̾νƮ National Academy of the Sciences ؼ £ ֱ а ̶ Ǵ°? ̰ ϴµ ʿ ̴.

̻ ġ ü ϴ ͻӸ ƴ϶, L Ϲ ڽ ϰ ߰ ü ϰ ִ. ״ ̱ ȸ ̱ ɸȸ Ἥ ڽ ˸⵵ ߴ. 1947⿡ ٽ Ƿ ִ. ôߴ ϴµ ʴ. ؾ ¥̰ ־ ģ δ. ״ Ȥ  ׿ ġ ڰ ־ ʾ, ״ 20 ġߴٰ ߴ. ״ ڽ , ˾, õ, (κ񰭿) ׵ Ȥ ƴٰ ߴ. ״ ӽ õ 4 ߿ ̶ ߴ. ̻ , ״ õ缺 ó ̾ ִٰ ϰ ִ. ׷, ڽ ȥ ǽ, ˾ ȯ Ӵϰ ȯڰ ʳ ڱÿ ־ ӽ õ߱ ̶ ± ĥ ־ٰ ϴ  ϴ ո δ. 

Shocked!

1958 Stillson Judah ͺ信 Ϲٵ ǥߴ. ״ ( ɸ) ؼ 亯 ٴ ̴. öе 亯 . ״ "ü, Ͽ, ĭƮ, Ȥ ö ȥ 𸣰 ֽϴ." ߴ. ̵ Ÿ ã⸸ Դϴ. ׷Ƿ ⿡ θ о߰ ֽϴ. ü Ͽ ȥ α ˱ ؼ Ÿ鼭 ãƴٳ°? ׷ ʴ´. ü Ͽʹ ٸ Ϲٵ " " ãҴ. ״ װ ãҴٰ ߴ. ٷ ϱ ؼ̴. ü Ͽ ƹ ٰ гȴ. ׵鿡Դ ü Ƴ ؼ ϴ ƴϴ. ׵ Ƴұ ϴ ̴. ڽŵ ؾ߰ڴٴ 屸 ü 쿬 ׵鿡 ſ ȣ ȯ ãƳ ʴ ̻ Ƴ . Ϸ 屸 ü ̴. 츮 ϱ ؼ 屸 ִ ƴ϶ 츮 屸 ֱ Ǵ ̴. ¶, ڱ 屸 ſ ϴٴ Ϲٵ尡 ߰ߴ .

Ϲٵ ϱ Ѵٴ  ߰߿,  entangling man ̶ ߴ. װ ü ? "״ ̹ ׸ Ͽ ڽ tangling Ѵ" ״ װ ̷ ׸ 1953 "ȥ " ϱ ؼ ġ (E-meter) ̿Ͽ ߴٰ Ѵ. 1951⿡ ׸ ִٴ ߰ߴٰ Ѵ. ٷ ΰ ȥ̾.

"Scientology Fundamentals"̶ ̿ 츮 " ȥ̴" Ư ִ. ̰ ٸ  ö, , Ȥ 󿡼 ãƺ ̴. ̰ Ƹ ұ ߴٰ ϴ Լ ̻ ̴. װ Ŭ ؼ о ʾ ̶ Ѵ. ̴ " öп Ұ"̴. ̱ ϳ ſ ªٴ ̰ ̾Ƴƽ ؼ ̾ ؼ б⿡ ٴ ̴. ź(ȥ) ڼ , ƽƮ ǰ ȥ ü иǴ Ͱ , ׸  ǽ  ϴ ؼ ϰ ʹ. ̰ ٸ ٷ ̴.[SD, "Dianetics"] ׷  ο뱸 ϰ װ ö ¤ Ѿڴ.

迡 ־ ϳ ϳ ȥ ִ ƴϸ ϳ ȥ 濡 Ȯ ... ó ̾ 8° dynamic ħ ʱ ۿ .

츮 뿡 ؼ . ¶, ٵ尡 ħ ʴ ٸ ȣۿ(interactionism)  ü ȣۿϴ° ǹ ̿ öп ߿ ̴. ٸ ü(substances) ǵǹǷ 亯 ʿϴ. īƮ ۰ (pineal gland) ׾ȿ ȴٰ ϹǷμ ذߴ. ٵ īƮ ٵ ȥ, , 3 ü ٿ ö̱ ̴. ׷ ״ ̵ ڰ ڿ ٸٰ ϸ,  ȣۿϴ° ֵ ִٴ ؾ . ״ ̷ ȣۿ Ͼ ʹ Ȯؼ ̰ ֿ ö ؾ . ״ ö ߽ ؼ ذ ̰ͻӸ ƴ϶ ؼ ؾ ִ. װ Ѱ öп ̸ Ű ؼ  ư ϴ° ̴.

̾ ֿ ŷ ϳ ̰ Ҹ Ѵٴ Ϳ ̴. "The Demystification of Death" 츮 Ϲ尡 α ȯ ʴٰ ܾϴ ؼ ߱ ȴ("A Note on Past Lives"). ̾ ȸ ɸڵ ݴ밡 DZ 信 ݴϴ ִ. ¶ų ̰ ̰ θ ϱ   ̷ ޾Ƶ̴ ̶ 䱸Ѵ. ״  "A Note on Past Lives" ̾Ƴƽ ̵ ǿ ־ٰ ߴ. ״ ̾Ʈ ٸ ̾ٴ ´ٰ ־.

"The Phenomena of Death," ٵ " ̾ ī ö ϰ ִ" ϰ ִ.  Ͼ° . Thetan (ȥ) ڽ ü ٴ (׾ٴ ) ߰Ѵ. ׸ ο ü ã ٴϰ ȴ. Thetan  Ÿ. ׸ ӽźθ ̸ ׳ฦ 󰣴. ״ thetan ӻΰ ̸ 2-3 ڿ Ʊ . thetan Ϲ ª ð  ȴ. ̰ ̾ ϰ ִ ̴. ü ٰŷ Ͼ ۿ . "A Note on Past Lives" ״ "и ¾ ̴ ٷ ׾ ̴." ϰ ִ. ׷Ƿ Ȥ ׳,  ⵿ ȯ Ǵ ̰ Ȥ ׳డ ִ ִ ð ȸϱ ؼ ȣ ʿϴ. и

"Dianetics, Scientology & Beyond" 츮 ٵ尡 " " Operating Thetans Ȥ OT θ ִ. OT "̰ õ Ҹ ȯ Ӵ" ̰ ұ ʹ ٸ ̴.

"Philosophy Wins after 2000 Years" ٵ ̾ ö и ϰԵǾ ϰ ִ. ٽ "ΰ ̸ ü ϸϾ ٴٿ ڹ̰ 쿬 ȭ ؼ ܳ" ȭϰ ִ. ̰ ̾θƮ ɸ ʴ´ٴ Ͱ ׵ ٴ ϰ ִ. ̰ , Ǵ ָ Ȥ ž" ִ ̰ų ƴϸ ̴̽. ٵ ϰ ̾ Ҹ꿡 亯 شٰ ִ. δ ̰ ̷ Ѵٰ ϴ ̴ Ȯ ̷ ʴ.  

CIA FBI ⵿ ̾ ǽ Ӹ ƴ϶ "̾ 㰡 ߴ" η ̴ ϼ ̴. ̰ ݱϿ ؼ ϴ ƴ϶, ö ׸ ۿ ؼ ϰ ִٰ ϰ ִ. ̾Ʈ "the state of the OT" ִ ٵ ° Ⱥ (National Security Agency) õ忡 ϰ ִ. 츮 ΰ ſ ʻ, Ʈ ׸ 忡 ؼ ӾҴٴ ߴٴ ׵ ̷ Ͼٸ ϴ.  

° ̴ ϰ"My Only Defense for Having Lived." ٿ. ̰ ̸ ȿ ٵ , , Ǵ Ƿ ̷ ƴ϶ Ѵ. ΰ ϴ ̴. ̴ ڼ ̴. ֳϸ ̾߱ ϱ Ʊ ̴. ƹ ̷ ̾߱⸦ ̴ٶ ״ Ѵ. , ״ ִ. ,  ؼ  ̿ ׻ ູϰ ´ٴ ˷ Ͽ ڰ ׸ ߹ߴ° ̾߱Ⱑ Ƿ ִ.  

, ̾Ʈ ̴ ٵ尡 "My Philosophy"̴. ̰ װ ϴ ̷ο ȭ ϰ ʹ ̰ . ״ 츮 Ͽ  " 屳  Ű̳ ź ." ϵǾ ִٰ Ѵ. Ƹ Ǿ ̰ 츮 װ Ⱥ̴ Ͽ ó ġ Ϳ ؼ ִ. ׷ ̰ Ǵ ݷ ؼǾ ̴.  

[RTC] October 22, 1996


further reading

reader comments

Churchland, Patricia Smith. Neurophilosophy - Toward a Unified Science of the Mind-Brain (Cambridge, Mass.: MIT Press, 1986). 

copyright 1998
Robert Todd Carroll

larrow.gif (1051 bytes) Jean Houston

Last updated 10/19/00


hundredth monkey phenomenon
rarrow.gif (1048 bytes)